It was not a good week for a lot of the members of the New Big East. With no league games on the docket, opportunities were plentiful to increase win totals against mostly middling competition. Unfortunately, 5 of the 9 teams that played this weekend lost and some of those that did win did so with their share of struggles. 6 teams hit the road and 4 of them returned home with a loss. Of course, this does nothing but muddle the middle of the conference and make the power rankings as much as a crapshoot after 4 weeks as they were after week 1. But on the positive side, the New Big East has 3 teams ranked in the AP poll (Louisville #19, Rutgers #23, and Boise State #24).
1. Louisville (4-0)
Last Week #1; This Week: Won 28-21 @ FIU
Teddy Bridgewater came back down to earth a little this week, but still did enough to get the Cardinals a win at FIU. Throwing more incomplete passes than he had in the previous three games combined, he was also picked off for the first time (actually, first two times). FIU was able to grab a 14-7 2nd quarter lead, but Louisville scored the next 21 points. A 4th-quarter Bridgewater interception gave FIU the ball deep in Louisville territory and set up the Panthers’ only 2nd half score, closing it to 28-21. But the Cardinals were able to pick up three first downs and run out the clock. They and their undefeated record head to Southern Mississippi this Saturday (CBSSN, 8pm).
2. Rutgers (4-0)
Last Week #3; This Week: Won 35-26 @ Arkansas
When you can give up 303 yards recieving and 3 TDs to a WR (like Rutgers did with Arkansas’ Cobi Hamilton) and still win by a two-possession margin, you’re doing OK. Coming into the game, I expected more from Rutgers’ defense, but never would have guessed that QB Gary Nova would go off like he did. 397 yards and 5 TDs later, Rutgers walked away from Fayetteville with a win and another can of gas poured on the dumpster fire that is Arkansas football. The Scarlet Knights head to UConn this weekend (ESPNU, Noon).
3. Cincinnati (2-0)
Last Week #2; This Week: Bye
I hope Cincinnati is well rested. After playing just two games in the first 4 weeks of the season, they head to FedEx Field to play Virginia Tech this weekend (ESPNU, 3:30pm). They won’t have another weekend off until after their season finale at Connecticut on December 1st. With Virginia Tech looking vulnerable, the Bearcats could be looking at a 6-0 start and a matchup of undefeateds with Louisville at the end of October.
4. Boise State (2-1)
Last Week #4; This Week: Won 7-6 vs. BYU
Had this game happened in the SEC, I’m sure we would have had a montage on Sportscenter of how awesome a defensive battle it was. But the truth, much like the truth of last year’s Bama-LSU slogfest in the regular season, was that neither team had much of an offense. Boise forced 5 turnovers (and never turned it over themselves) and held BYU to 200 yards, 95 of which came on BYU’s last possession and only scoring drive. After the late TD, Bronco Mendenhall rolled the dice (against a team that had no faith in their kicker) and went for a two-point conversion that fell short. The highlight of the night, of course, was the defensive TD by the Broncos’ nose tackle, Mike Atkinson, after he picked off BYU QB Riley Nelson and rumbled 36 yards to paydirt. It’s clear Kellen Moore is missed, but looking at the MWC schedule for Boise, it’s possible they don’t lose again before heading to Nevada in their season finale. Boise opens that conference schedule this week at New Mexico (local TV only, 6pm).
5. UCF (2-1)
Last Week #7; This Week: Bye
Now we get into the messier part of the power rankings. UCF moves up to #5 by virtue of a bye week and their inability to notch a loss against it. This week they’re visited by a Missouri team that’s been pounded on during their first two SEC games, the latest a 31-10 loss at South Carolina (FSN, Noon).
6. UConn (2-2)
Last Week #5; This Week: Lost 24-30 @ Western Michigan
It’s never a good look to drop a game to a directional Michigan school, even if you are on the road. UConn never led in the game. The Huskies were in Western Michigan territory with less than 8 minutess to go in the game, down by a touchdown, but a 53-yard fumble return for a TD by the Broncos put the game out of reach. With Rutgers coming to town, it’s likely the Huskies fall below .500 for the first time this year (ESPNU, Noon)
7. USF (2-2)
Last Week #6; This Week: Lost 27-31 @ Ball State
In a game that went back and forth, it was Willie Snead’s 11th and final catch that gave the Cardinals the victory over the Bulls. BJ Daniels continues to put up BJ Daniels stats – 19/30, 312 yds, 3 TD, and 2 INT – and losing in the most BJ Daniels of ways. After starting at the USF 13 with just 1:02 to go, Daniels drove the Bulls to the Ball State 28 yard line and then was picked off at the 10 to end the game. Of course, all of that will be forgiven if the Bulls can somehow pull off the monumental upset when #4 Florida State visits this weekend (ESPN, 6pm).
8. SDSU (2-2)
Last Week #8; This Week: Lost 28-34 vs. San Jose State
If you just look at who they have lost to, I could probably move SDSU up ahead of UConn and USF in the rankings of 2-2 teams. San Jose State doesn’t seem to be the laughingstock team they were just a couple of years ago (great news for Navy, whom the Spartans visit this weekend), with their only loss being by 3 to now #8 Stanford. But wins over Army and North Dakota don’t really prove a lot, and so they stay below the other 2-2 teams. The Aztecs head to Fresno State this weekend for a late game (local TV only, 10pm).
9. Temple (1-2)
Last Week #9; This Week: Lost 13-24 @ Penn State
Honestly, the only reason Temple’s above Navy is because they lost to Penn State by less. When you look at the box scores and drive charts, it’s clear Navy shot themselves in the foot more than Temple did vs. the Nittany Lions. Navy’s offense put up more yards. Whatever. This is the anti-homer ranking of the week. Temple gets to be the best 1-2 team – hooray. They have a bye this week before South Florida visits October 6th.
10. Navy (1-2)
Last Week #11; This Week: Won 41-3 vs. VMI
It started out extremely ugly. So ugly that Navy QB Trey Miller was on the verge of getting pulled in the 1st half after turning the ball over twice. But Coach Niumatalolo stuck with Miller and it paid off. While the Navy defense harassed VMI all afternoon, allowing just 3 drives of more than 25 yards, Miller got his act together and rushed for 116 yards and 3 TDs while throwing for another 107 on 50% passing. Hopefully the Midshipmen can build on this. San Jose State visits this week (CBSSN, 3:30pm) and then it’s off to Colorado Springs to take on an Air Force team that just lost to UNLV (snicker).
11. SMU (1-2)
Last Week #10; This Week: Bye
SMU just drew the short straw from the 1-2 teams thanks to their bye week. Given how badly they have lost to Texas A&M and Baylor this year, I don’t expect too much positive from the Mustangs when #15 TCU visits this weekend (FSN, 6pm)
12. Houston (0-3)
Last Week #12; This Week: Bye
The good news is you can’t lose to a bye week. The bad news is you could possibly lose to Rice this weekend at Reliant Stadium (FSN, 3:30pm).
13. Memphis (0-4)
Last Week #13; This Week: Lost 14-38 @ Duke
I don’t even know what to say about Memphis these days. They turned Duke over 4 times, never turned it over themselves, but still managed just 152 yards and 9 first downs. I guess it’s good that Memphis had the lead a couple of times in the 1st half and held Duke scoreless in the first quarter. But after their TD with 9:17 to go in the first half, Memphis didn’t see the Duke side of the field until there were under six minutes left in the game. This team is bad. What does the San Jose TV market look like? Is it too late to do a swap? Memphis gets a bye this week before getting Rice at home October 6th.
14 thoughts on “New Big East Power Rankings – Week 4”
So if we beat San Jose St this week, we move above Temple since they have a Bye?
If we beat them we move past Temple because SJSU is a quality win
Pitt beats VT
Cinn beats Pitt
Sequitur: Cinn beats VT.
Biggest downstream problem for Big East will be preventing defection of Louisville to Big 12.
i don’t see why the Big XII would want to expand beyond where they are today. they have an extremely rich TV contract, on that Louisville isn’t really going to move the needle. And the lack of a conference championship game is going to help them in the long run. Their teams don’t have to play that extra game that members of the ACC, B1G, PAC-12, SEC have to play now after the season. Those are often a chance for an undefeated team to stumble.
Big 12 Board of Commissioners already announced they are looking to expand…still desperately want BYU and Louisville.
Championship game brings revenue.
History of Big 12 defections and expansion here:
Those comments are a year old. You’ll find much more recent ones saying that they’re content at 10. The revenue that a championship game would bring wouldn’t come close to offsetting the per-school revenue loss that would come from splitting TV money 12 ways instead of 10.
here’s something a little newer for you
as mike said, they’re happy where they are. and even if they did go to 12, they wouldn’t necessarily go to a title game. the revenue from having a team or two in the playoffs that will be starting soon is going to be greater than a relatively regional conference title game
Louisville is not going anywhere. Notre Dame to the ACC has basically stopped major expansion.
Anybody have thoughts (Not in this crowd, right?) about the Big East move now that the playoff system has stated to take shape and it looks like the Big East will get left out of the major bowls? Personally, I don’t think the ND/ACC “Friends with Privileges” relationship helped. Will the Big East become a lesser conference and leave us in the same place we were trying to avoid (for the record, I think the Big East Move is necessary for all the reason already discussed)
Notre Dame joining the ACC might’ve been the best thing to happen to Big East football.
Yeah, what Mike said. I think that the ND move this year might cool off the talk about expansion for a while – at least above the Big East. The Big East will still look to go to 14 or 16 football teams to finish off their moves. But unless Notre Dame finds that they have to join the ACC full time (thus pushing the ACC to add one more team for symmetry), I just can’t see any moves happening.
Now, as far as the bowls are concerned, we’re still waiting to see. The playoffs will pit the Top 4 teams against each other, so if Louisville or Boise or any other BE team ends up that high, no worries. The worry is what happens to the best teams that aren’t in the Top 4 and exist outside of the ACC/B1G/PAC/SEC/XII.
There has been discussion of adding a seventh – yes seventh – bowl to the rotation of bowls that will host semifinal games and using that bowl as a landing sport for the best team from the Big East and/or the lower conferences. Stewart Mandel wrote a piece on CNNSI about it and the creep the new system has going back to the old BCS.
So long story short, there probably will be a landing spot for the BE. And Navy will be included in all of the above should they ever have a miracle season. Regardless, being in the BE with the new system helps us maintain a national profile while other leagues go to 9 game schedules and non-con games dry up.
and don’t forget TV. Who knows what TV Air Force and Army will be on in five years.
what, you don’t get Root and Altitude? lol
who knew there was a TV deal out there that would look the MTN look successful