Football practice started two weeks ago. Media day is done, the first scrimmage is in the books, and the season is officially underway. Usually around this time I start blathering about how the summer felt so short and that I’m not sure if I’m ready to start again blah blah blah. That mess won’t fly this year, since I basically took the second half of last season off. I might end up doing the same thing this year, but for now I’ll fool myself into thinking that I’m gung-ho.  Time to get crackin’. I have a lot of work to catch up on. The next week will be dedicated to clearing out my DVR and putting a bunch of games on DVD. That, and maybe I should actually write a thing or two. LOLLERS LET’S NOT GET TOO FAR AHEAD OF OURSELVES.

Anyway, a new season brings all the usual questions as we try to sift through the unknown. How do the new players look, how are the position battles shaping up, how do you fight complacency… You know the drill. This year it also brings a few not-so-usual questions too, as the Mids come into 2011 with someone else on the top of the service academy heap for the first time in a long time. The last time a Navy team started the season without the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy in Bancroft Hall, most of the current plebe class was entering fifth grade. It’s a weird feeling. If you’re in search of silver linings, that probably takes care of the whole “complacency” thing. The other questions are in the process of being sorted out.

Most of those questions come on the defensive side of the ball, where Jabaree Tuani, Max Blue, and Kwesi Mitchell are the only starters returning from a year ago. The last time we saw this kind of turnover was 2007, and those were some dark days. That was a bit of a different situation, though, since a slew of injuries pressed a bunch of freshmen and sophomores into starting roles. That isn’t the case this year. Of course, I said the exact same thing going into last year, and while the 2010 defense wasn’t anywhere near as bad as they were in 2007, they were incredibly erratic. Against Maryland, the run defense let everything through like it would’ve been impolite not to. A week later against Georgia Southern, they were fantastic. If tackling is an art, then the Notre Dame game was the Louvre while the Duke game the following week was more like those galleries that show crucifixes made of poop. Sure, you could say that some of the inconsistency stemmed from who they were playing, but we even saw Jekyll & Hyde performances in the same game like in the first and second halves against SMU. It was crazy, and it’ll be hard to build consistency in 2011 with the unit breaking in 8 new starters.

Hard, but not impossible. When you look at Navy’s recruiting classes over the last 2-3 years, the majority of the players that had other I-A offers were on the defensive side of the ball. Athletically, the defense is as good it’s ever been.  And while there aren’t many returning starters, that doesn’t mean these guys are devoid of experience, especially on the defensive line. It’s the linebackers that are the biggest unknown, but the coaches have said a lot of good things about Jarred Shannon and Mason Graham, and the inside linebackers all stood out because of their hard work  in the offseason strength and conditioning program. The pieces look like they’re in place, so there’s a reason for a measure of optimism. Anything more than that would just be blind faith.

The offense is a different story, with 4 returning starters on the offensive line, both starting slotbacks, Alex Teich at fullback, and a senior quarterback in Kriss Proctor that has seen plenty of reps and knows the offense cold. Aaron Santiago is finally healthy, and together with Gee Gee Greene they give the Mids a one-two punch at slot that we haven’t seen since Reggie and Zerb. The entire slotback rotation is stacked, for that matter. Even the wide receivers have been making plays in practice, although with Proctor not exactly known as a gunslinger it’s unlikely that they’ll be catching as many passes as they did last year.

The passing game might be the only potential hiccup in this offense. There was a time when Navy fans held their collective breath whenever the Mids dropped back to pass, but that changed a bit with Ricky Dobbs at quarterback. Ricky had a strong and accurate arm that made passing a viable and routine alternative in the Navy arsenal. While that kind of passing ability is more of a luxury than a necessity in this scheme, you do need to be able to connect on play action downfield. Navy’s defensive philosophy revolves around preventing the big play, with the idea that the more snaps you force an offense to take, the more likely they are to make a mistake. The same applies to the Navy offense as well; more snaps, more opportunity for error. That’s why you have to take advantage of big plays in the passing game when that’s what the defense is giving you. Remember the Delaware game in 2003? The Blue Hens completely sold out on the option and ignored pass defense altogether. Early on, the Mids were able to take advantage and shot out to a 14-0 lead after Craig Candeto connected with Eric Roberts on a long TD pass. But Delaware stuck to their game plan, and the Mids weren’t able to make those pass plays consistently. They would end up losing to Delaware 21-17. Last year, when Louisiana Tech tried the same thing, the Mids responded with 219 yards passing and a 37-23 win.

Kriss doesn’t have to throw like Ricky to make this offense go, but he does have to throw well enough to at least give the defense something to think about. He’s been compared to Kaipo more than once due to their mutual grasp of the offense. Something else Kaipo was known for early in his career was having a noodle arm. By the time he graduated, though, Kaipo had developed into a pretty good passer. It rarely looked pretty when he dropped back to throw, but it was effective. If Kriss can even come close to making that kind of progress, this might be the best Navy offense of the last decade. If not, it’ll still be pretty good. It will have to be with the schedule that the Mids will be facing this year.

So that’s how I see things coming into 2011. Thoughts?


  1. tphuey

    Agree. I had the same flashbacks to the 2007 defense, and I don’t think we will be that bad. However, if the offense is like the 2007 offense, I don’t think anybody will complain! :)

  2. 81Zoltan

    I believe we will not know what this team is made of until Saturday 1 October, Air Force at Navy-Marine Corps. First three games Navy will either be big favorite or big underdog (Delaware game will be fairly even match-up as usual).

    Fortunately, Navy has an open date on 24 September, while Air Force is playing Tennessee State on that date. Hopefully AF will be peeking past USNA at Norte Dame, which it plays the week after Navy.

  3. Edgar Alverson

    Do we know anything about Prentice Christian or Delvin Diggs? Any depth behind Teich? And how close is Trey Miller?

    No doubt Miller and one of those FBs will have chances to prove themselves at some point.

  4. Section 130

    one distraction Navy won’t have is last year’s irrational optimism going into the opener with Maryland..sobriety is its own reward…

  5. EKWJR

    Don’t know if it is Dobbs hangover and I am expecting too much, but Proctor looked very bad passing the ball on Saturday. I would not be surprised to see Delaware repeat 2003 again this year and ignore Navy’s passing game.

  6. Woody87

    I recall Polanco as being a weak thrower – and erratic the few times I saw him throw as a backup 2nd classman. But as a firstie he had some stunning completions. and not a bad receiver either. Anyway, hoping Kriss will get some of that magic this season…

  7. usmc53

    The biggest hole in the D might be trying to replace Wyatt. His backup (Frazer?) didn’t exactly dazzle me in his limited time last year.

  8. EKWJR

    On backup FB…IJ has nice things to say about Diggs and how he answered the call against WF last season…the coaches place high value of performance in games…Diggs also looked improved last Saturday.

    Fraser is way down the depth chart now and was nearly invisible last Saturday. It appears Mitchell has been moved to the back because of lack of steady performance by anyone else.

    Miller looked OK but he just does not look ready yet.

  9. Navy72


    Good points all. I sense that this team learned lesson from last year’s hype about a Heisman for Dobbs and an undefeated season.

    Do you have any thoughts about Navy’s back-up QB? Looking at last several years, we’ve had to rely on the back-up to step in a start multiple games?

  10. Dave'69

    Mike – thanks for your post. Getting anxious about the start of the season.
    I agree with your above comments re back-up QB however I’d add the words “… the hard way.” It would be nice if one or both of the first two games allow us to get a look at some of the back-ups at all positions as we play out a victory in the 4th. Whatever the outcome, I’ll be standing in front of my TV for the playing of Blue and Gold and in front of the team in Columbia. Looking forward to meeting you there.

  11. gonavy921

    Proctors durability will be huge this year. I think we’ll see Miller and find out were he stands in the O. Hopefully Wright steps up in the secondary, we need help there…

  12. Edgar Alverson

    I saw Trey Miller in high school… He was off the charts, but in a weak (mostly private school) classification. Still, the fact that he won the Spring award sends a serious message to the team. From a distant view, it looks like Trey will get opportunities soon…

  13. daphillips1

    As I recall, Lamar Owens was the last QB to start every game in a season. It appeared that he was very elusive and good at avoiding direct hits. Let’s hope that Proctor has the same ability.

  14. Navyrugger

    It would be nice to get some backups PT the first few weeks but I’m more concerned about getting Ws. Look at the last couple years – there have been maybe two games (Rice 09 and ECU 10) where the backups got PT in a route. Let’s not get beyond ourselves. We are 2-2 v Delaware the last 4 games, they will bring it. And WKU has a hell of a back. No gimmes when you are Navy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s