Now that vacations are over and it’s back to the blogging grind, it’s time to get back to the polls, too. In today’s poll, we pay homage to the forward pass. Even though Navy has earned its reputation as the nation’s finest running team, this strange and wondrous contraption has also been known to create a big play from time to time. Navy’s slotbacks and wide receivers spend most of their time blocking or running the ball, but they tend to get a lot of bang for their buck when the ball is passed their way.

So today’s question is: who made the most of those opportunities? Since 2002, who do you think is Navy’s best receiver? Or maybe I should say “catcher of passes” instead of “receiver” so people don’t think I’m only referring to WRs. Whatever, you get the point.


  1. jgish

    I voted for Tyree but ERob made the single most awesomest catch that I can remember in the Army Navy game (I think). I would probably vote JT second.

  2. jimbear

    Tyree was the best receiver. The highest rated by the draft gurus. JT had more catches but I don’t think he was as talented. Reggie was the most fun to watch once he got the ball in his hands.

  3. Astor

    yeah, I agree with both – Tyree was the purest and most talented receiver though he didn’t get as many opportunities to catch the ball as Tomlinson (who I think is second). They both have unreal hands, and both ran great routes, but Tyree also had that speed and was far more explosive.

  4. EKW JR

    Hands-wise, Roberts, Thomlinson and Barnes are at the top IMO and indistinguishable, but when you think about “Pontiac Game Changing Moments” it’s Reggie, in a landslide:

    05 Colorado State – opening play – hello!
    06 UConn – opening play – hello!
    07 ND Dame in OT – adios!

  5. Gary

    I voted from recall and after I think Jason Tomlinson stood out for me.
    I tried to keep it wide receiver as opposed to slots.
    God Bless Rob Taylor!

  6. NavyInsider

    Agreed, I have him second, but in my mind there is Tyree and then everybody else. Plus, you asked us to vote for first not first and second :)

  7. NavyInsider

    I am going to have to disagree. It isn’t close. Not at all. Tyree is head and shoulders above JT. Bigger, stronger, faster, better hands. Tyree made some unbelievable catches in his career. JT would not be in my top 5.

  8. Anonymous

    No doubt about it, Tyree. Big, strong,and fast. Opposing teams knew he was basically the only option and he still made the plays. There were several times when he got behind the defense but they couldn’t get the ball to him.

  9. Knine

    One of the best catches was Marco Nelson catching a long ball against Stanford and doing a 360 after the catch before running into the endzone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s